From what we’ve been seeing from Republicans supposedly “negotiating” on health care reform, it’s reasonable to ask if they are negotiating or obstructing. Negotiating presumes a willingness to compromise. Each side gives something to arrive at a solution. While nobody gets all they want, neither do they have to give up everything. But compromise seems to be operative only among Democrats. Republicans, on the other hand, continue to throw up roadblock after roadblock each time the Democrats show any signs of compromise. Is compromise viewed as weakness among Republicans? It would seem so.
Perhaps this debate has brought into focus a fundamental difference between today’s Democrats and Republicans. I saw the first indications of it during a GOP governor’s first term in New Mexico nearly 20 years ago. But the mantra can be characterized by Ronald Regan’s pronouncement that government is the problem. A Republican who had run a successful business ran for and was elected governor of New Mexico. As owner of a business, he was accustomed to getting his way, to having people do what he asked them to do. After all, if they didn’t, he could fire them. But he quickly discovered that governing is an entirely different activity, requiring both the ability and the willingness to negotiate and to compromise. And therein lies the difference. It appears that Democrats truly want to govern, while Republicans prefer ruling.
The kind and tone of the opposition has made it apparent that the only “reform” the GOPers are interested in is no reform. Oh, they mouth words that say they support reform, but they aren’t contributing anything positive to the debate. They talk privatization, letting the market rule. Well, just look at the financial collapse last fall and you have a really good assessment of how well unregulated markets work. Why, even Alan Greenspan, that beacon of free-market capitalism, has admitted that it didn’t work very well.
Finally, a member of Congress has called it like it is in an op-ed piece in USA Today. He says it’s time to forget bipartisanship and use the tools available to make the large Democratic majorities in both houses of Congress work like they’re supposed to.
The Gang of Six seems to be crumbling. Yesterday there were hints that even without a public option, the GOP members of the group were demanding additional concessions. Sen. Grassley (R-IA) allowed as how he wouldn’t vote for anything but a “perfect” bill. By today he is saying that bipartisanship is impossible. Also today, Sen. Jeff Bingaman (D-NM) suggested that the reconciliation process might be the only path to reform. That is unfortunate, but without cooperation from Republicans, it’s the only way.
It’s time to listen to the American people instead of the corporate shills. The shills have stirred up enough trouble, enough hate and discontent. In case you’re still laboring under the impression that “ordinary Americans” are populating those raucous town hall meetings, ask yourself why they only show up at meetings held by Democrats. Then, look at the chart below, which was published today by the Campaign for America’s Future.
We’ve been waiting for health care reform for decades. It’s time to stop letting Sen. Grassley’s perfect become the enemy of the good. Let’s pass it, see how it works, then tinker with the parts that need improvement. Otherwise, we’ll continue to see the numbers of uninsured rise along with costs. Republicans cried that Social Security and Medicare were socialism. Democrats ignored the naysayers and passed both. Now, they are integral parts of our social safety net, programs that while imperfect, are considered essential by all but the most reactionary people among us.
Read Full Post »